Melissa Calusinski was convicted in 2012 of murdering 16-month-old Benjamin Kingan at a day care center in Lincolnshire, IL by throwing him to the floor.
She “confessed” after a 10-hour interrogation, but has always maintained her innocence.
CBS “48 Hours” will air a report on the case Saturday, Feb. 28 at 10:00 PM EST. See a preview here.
See the Chicago Tribune story from March, 2012 here.
We’ve posted before about “dog scent lineups.” See those posts here and here. They’ve been called “the worst of the junk sciences.”
I can do naught but shake my head. I thought we had seen the last of it, but this stuff is still going on. In Maricopa County, AZ, not one, but two, people were charged with setting their own houses on fire, based upon bogus dog scent evidence which was solely the result of unethical conduct by the Phoenix Fire Department investigators involved. An independent, professional fire investigator confirmed without question that the fires were NOT arson. The charges against both were eventually dismissed, but not before one of them spent 16 months in jail.
See the aol.com Inside Edition story here … it should make you angry.
And here’s the kicker. Despite the recommendation of six felony charges, the prosecutor declined to bring any charges against the dishonest fire department employees, and they are both still employed by the department.
Looks like the “good ol’ boy” network is alive and well in Maricopa County.
Christopher Abernathy, 48, was released from prison on Wednesday after Cook County (IL) Judge Frank Zelezinski vacated his 1987 conviction for a rape and murder Cook County (IL) officials now acknowledge he did not commit. Abernathy had served nearly 30 years of a life sentence for the crime.
Cook County State’s Attorney Anita Alvarez’s Conviction Integrity Unit reviewed DNA evidence from the crime, presented by Abernathy’s attorneys, which Continue reading
We have reported numerous times before about how malleable human memory can be (here and here) and on the dangers of the Reid Technique of interrogation that arise from this (here and here).
On Feb. 3, Mark Godsey posted this article from the LawTimesNews describing the resesarch of Prof. Stephen Porter and Julia Shaw. The study demonstrated that it is relatively easy to get people to “remember” details of a crime they never committed.
Our sincere thanks to the publisher of the study, SAGE Publications, for allowing us to post a link to the full text of the research article. The link will be active until March 5, 2015. See the full text here: Constructing Rich False Memories of Committing Crime.
This excerpt from the abstract of the article: “It appears that in the context of a highly suggestive interview, people can quite readily generate rich false memories of committing crime.” And of course, for the term “highly suggestive interview” we can substitute “Reid Technique.”
In case you haven’t been able to check in on the National Registry of Exonerations lately, here’s an excerpt from the most recent data. Note the total is now up to 1,512, and the trend line is definitely UP.
I won’t belabor you by pointing out some of the more obvious observations. Just a few minutes of study will (should) lead you to some very clear conclusions.
It has been reported that the folks at the Registry are hard at work trying to incorporate the exonerations being generated by the newly formed “conviction integrity units” (CIU’s). For these cases the prosecutors running the CIU’s may not be very motivated to have their exonerations logged into the Registry.
I can’t gush enough about how critical and important this data is. It is this kind of HARD DATA that will provide the foundation for much needed and long overdue justice system reform.
Posted in DNA, Editorials/Opinion, Exonerations, Eyewitness identification, False confessions, Forensic controls, Junk science, Police conduct (good and bad), Prosecutorial conduct (good and bad), Reforming/Improving the system, Snitching
Dan Gristwood was convicted in 1996 of attempted murder for beating his wife with a hammer. He signed a confession, that he did not write, after 16 hours of interrogation by the NY State Police.
In 2003, the real attacker, Mastho Davis, came forward and confessed. Gristwood was released in 2005, and ultimately awarded $7.5M for his nine years of wrongful incarceration.
Sadly, on January 3, 2015, four months after receiving payment, Dan Gristwood died from lung cancer. See the ABC News story here.
The syracuse.com story about the case here is definitely worth a read, and reads like a script for the prototypical coerced confession.
In light of all the recent public – and police – furor about police conduct, and how they relate to the community, and how they should be respected, I can do naught but shake my head. When the police do stuff like this, how can they claim any high ground in this discussion? Dan Gristwood, after his release, said he thought the problem was a “few bad apples.” That may very well be so, but guess what? Those “few” bad apples make the whole barrel stink. And this problem belongs to the police – not the public.