Murder of One Gets Death Sentence

Read about the current state of capital punishment in Japan here.

A 30-year-old man from Osaka was sentenced to death last week. What was unusal about this sentence is that the defendant had no prior criminal record, and that it was a case involving the death of a single victim.

In the 1983 Nagayama decision, the Supreme Court stated that the courts must be extremely cautious to impose the death penalty. It stated that they could impose death penalty only where the below stated nine factors were considered and where the death penalty is deemed compelling.

The nine factors are: seriousness of the offence, motive, how the crime was committed; especially the manner of the murder, seriousness of the outcome of the crime; especially the number of victims, sentiments of victim’s family members, impact on society, defendant’s age, prior record/ criminal history, and degree of remorse.

When the courts take these factors into consideration, it  is standard practice that they do not sentence one to the death penalty when the case involves a single victim and the defendant has no prior criminal record. Thus, the case last week came to a shock to many.

From the Japan Times:

Killer of one had no rap sheet, sentenced to hang

Kyodo, Feb. 16, 2013

In what appears to be a first in the judicial system, an Osaka man has been sentenced to hang for killing a woman even though there was only one victim and the perpetrator had no previous criminal record.

Judge Kosuke Morioka of the Okayama District Court, presiding over a panel of professional and lay judges trying Koichi Sumida, 30, said Thursday the victim was also sexually assaulted, making the case “grave.”

Sumida’s lawyer immediately appealed the sentence.

The defendant was convicted of robbing Misa Kato, a 27-year-old temp staff worker and colleague, of around ¥24,000 in cash and personal belongings on Sept. 30, 2011, at a warehouse in the city of Okayama where they worked.

Sumida then assaulted her sexually and stabbed her to death. He dismembered her body and dumped the remains in Osaka.

He was charged with robbery, rape, murder and damaging and dumping a corpse. During the trial he owned up to the charges and said he felt no pity for the victim.

In a Feb. 7 session, however, he apologized in tears to the victim’s family. His lawyer asked for a less severe sentence than death, saying Sumida was repentant.

He is the 16th defendant to be sentenced to death since the lay judge system was introduced in May 2009.

It is the third time the ultimate penalty has been imposed in a case involving only one victim, but in the previous two cases the defendants committed murder within months after leaving prison for previous crimes — one for a murder and the other for robbery resulting in injury.

Lead Judge Morioka said the motive for the crime was to “work off sexual frustration” and “there is little likelihood of rehabilitation.”

Morioka said that it was “not appropriate to consider” Sumida’s lack of a criminal record, given that “the defendant’s inclination toward committing a crime cannot be ruled out.”

One response to “Murder of One Gets Death Sentence

  1. A dead victim is still dead. The perp should die the same way as the victim – that would certainly deter some criminals. I have a personal interest in seeing justice done, having lost a son to homicide that has not and will not be prosecuted in Pennsylvania. A dead murderer will not be a repeat offender.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s