How the Courts Trap People Who Have Been Convicted by Bad Forensics

Radley Balko, investigative reporter for the Washington Post, has just published an article dealing with the justice system’s refusal/inability to deal appropriately with false, fake, unscientific, and discredited forensic evidence post conviction.

The focus is on a case that involves the infamous Dr. Steven Hayne, a now thoroughly discredited expert witness, who was sole medical examiner for the state of Mississippi for 20 years.  I urge you to read the entire article, but I’ve extracted a few particularly telling quotes:

•  “The courts and the people who operate in them seem to feel that the integrity of the system demands the preservation of verdicts.”

Addressing the fact that the body of scientific knowledge grows as a process, rather than an event; coupled with the legal time restrictions for introduction of new evidence  ————

•  “From the perspective of the wrongly convicted, you can see the trap here. File too soon, and the court may conclude that you haven’t presented enough evidence that the forensic theory upon which you were convicted has been discredited. If you then try to file more petitions as more evidence comes out to bolster your argument, you risk the court concluding that this is an  issue you’ve already raised, you lost, and you’re therefore barred from raising it again.”

•  “Koon was convicted due to testimony from an expert the court now admits isn’t credible. For the same court to nevertheless uphold his conviction because he missed a deadline is to keep him in prison on a technicality. It’s a cynical outcome that suggests the criminal justice system values process more than justice.”

Read the story by Radley Balko of the Washington Post here.


4 responses to “How the Courts Trap People Who Have Been Convicted by Bad Forensics

  1. Phil, Excellent. A topic that needs to be covered. “Death by deadline” must be changed.

  2. I was wrongfully convicted as a result of a now discredited NYPD lab technician, Mariem Megalla who falsified drug lab results in my case in 2007. I testified that this is a case of tampering of evidence and police corruption. However, i had no credible proof other than my word. As s result I was sentenced to 8 yrs for allegedly possessing less than a gram of crack cocaine. As a result, my infant son Isaiah was illegally removed from my home from under the care of his paternal grandmother and thrust into the foster care system with a non relative foster mom instead of with my son’s own family. I sued the NYPD for documents which I now have and will show the many violations that was used to wrongfully convict me. To hear more of this story please check out also Google Mariem Megalla the Huffington post article by Anthony Papa and Counter Punch, the case of Mariem Megalla. If anyone can help my family to address this injustice that plagues our failing system and right a wrong please e-mail me at and or leave a comment. I’m also on LinkedIn under Djuan Collins. Thank you and God Bless

  3. Pingback: Mississippi Supreme Court Overturns Conviction involving Steven Hayne, Shaken Baby Syndrome | Wrongful Convictions Blog

  4. DJuan E Collins

    I have a criminal case involving a disgraced NYPD lab technician named Mariem Megalla who falsified drug lab results in over 3,000 cases that she handled. Mines is one of them. I have evidence that she “dry-labbed” my case as well as thousands of others but through a “Blue-Wall” this Scandal has been covered up by top level officials, judges, prosecutors, attorneys. I have two different spectragraph analysis. One from 2007 and an alleged reanalysis in 2010. A purity level of 70.8% was revealed in 2007 and in 2010 a purity level of 72.2%. I have anecdotal evidence that the reanalysis is not from the same sample in 2007. So we have records fraud, treason against the constitution, domestic terrorism, oath of office violation, etc. I would like to expose this corrupt government in the Manhattan D.A, criminal justice and NYPD system. As a result of this wrongful conviction I lost my parental rights to my son Isaiah who was wrongfully removed from my home in November 2007 under an emergencyremoval from his paternal grandmother who was a registered nurse by ACS. Overturning this criminal conviction opens the door to reuniting my son Isaiah with his natural loving family in Chicago. My son was illegally adopted by a non relative foster mom instead of placing my son with his own natural family while I was wrongfully in prison fighting the criminal charges as well as a wrongful termination of my parental rights. I have evidence to corroborate my story. Please help me in my 13yr fight to Saving Isaiah 🙏🙏🙏

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s