Texas Legislature is Addressing Wrongful Conviction

An opinion (here) in The Stateman (Austin) yesterday commended the Texas legislature for pending legislation aimed at reducing wrongful conviction. After some challenge by district attorneys and a resulting amendment that protects witnesses and victims, the Texas Senate unanimously passed Senate Bill 1611, known as the Michael Morton bill, which would create a uniform “open file” policy in the state, thus requiring the prosecution to share all files with defense attorneys.

According to the opinion piece, the Senate has also passed a bill “that would give exonerated Texans four years from the date of their release from prison to pursue allegations that a prosecutor hid evidence. The statute of limitations currently begins at the time a violation occurs — a provision that makes it all but impossible to hold prosecutors accountable.”

Another bill awaiting a House hearing “would give Texas courts the authority to overturn convictions based on new science that contradicts evidence used during a trial.”

The opinion notes that in addition to inestimable human suffering, wrongful conviction has been costly to Texas taxpayers. “Since 1992, about $65 million have been paid to people who spent time in prison for crimes they did not commit.”

This, of course, does not include the human and financial costs of incarcerating innocent people and of subsequent crimes committed by the real perpetrators who escaped justice.

Case in point: Michael Morton served nearly 25 years in prison after being wrongfully convicted in the beating death of his wife Christine. DNA eventually linked the crime to Mark Alan Norwood. Morton was exonerated amid allegations of prosecutorial misconduct in the form of failure to share exculpatory evidence with the defense. Norwood was convicted of the crime and sentenced to life in prison. Norwood also has been charged with the 1988 beating death of Debra Baker in her Austin home, which occurred while the innocent Morton was in prison. This tragic example of bungled justice—among many others—should motivate citizens, criminal justice professionals, and legislators well beyond Texas to commit to best practices and reforms that can reduce wrongful conviction. Enough is enough.

7 responses to “Texas Legislature is Addressing Wrongful Conviction

  1. I find it both remarkable and encouraging that Texas is seemingly setting something of an example for other states. Perhaps this is partly driven by the fact that its past performance in these regards has been so egregious.

  2. Phil, I agree. The state has experienced many miscarriages but it also has heroes among its public officials and Innocence workers. Let’s hope these legislative measures pass and prompt initiatives in other states to correct outdated laws and requirements to be consistent with post-DNA understandings.

  3. Ryan Ferguson is an innocent Missouri man wrongly convicted of a crime he had nothing to do with. He has been incarcerated for over 9 years even though the only witnesses have since recanted and admitted to perjury under oath. Please read more at FreeRyanFerguson.com JusticeForRyanFerguson.com and if you would like to support Ryan, you may sign the Petition (Change.Org) and “Like” the Free Ryan Ferguson Facebook page.

  4. Pingback: Michael Morton Act to Become Texas Law on September 1 | Wrongful Convictions Blog

  5. Cause # 40748 of Burnet County Texas Took only less than 8 hours. Wrongful conviction took place on August 12th of 2013 Judge boast about this being his 12th jury trial in the short time he’s been on bench. Tells jury not to take to much time on the case 2 or 3 days. ineffectiveness assistant of
    of counsel. Mental Illness, and 18 years of taking Prozac and Olanzapine risks and effects of a veteran squashed. Prosecutor line of questioning did pertain to the charge. Prosecutor’s witness and a jury member went to school with each other.

  6. making the 13th day of August his 13th jury trial

Leave a Reply to Brenda Franks Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s