Author Archives: Carole McCartney

Scottish Fingerprint Inquiry Report

ImageWhile we’re on the subject of fingerprints, with the publication of the NIST report into human factors and fingerprints just out, in case you missed it – you can read the final report into the Shirley McKie fingerprint mis-identification case at the website of the Scottish Fingerprint Inquiry that came out in Decemeber 2011. It is a very thorough report into not just this case, but the use of fingerprints and the ‘ACE-V’ system as well as process issues.

Newest Australian Miscarriages of Justice Campaign Group

Perth, Western Australia will be home to an international conference of legal and forensic experts next month, hosted by ‘Justice WA’ – a new campaign group that is hoping to take on its first case next year and wants to establish a criminal cases committee to investigate miscarriages of justice. Read more on the conference here…. You can visit JusticeWA website here…

Gordon Wood exonerated in Australian murder case

ImageGordon Wood, convicted in 2008 of murdering his girlfriend in 1995 by throwing her from a cliff, has had his conviction overturned in Sydney, after serving 3 1/2 years of his 13 year sentence. The judges at appeal decided that there was sufficient doubt about the expert evidence in the case, that Wood should win his appeal and he was freed later that day. Read more about the appeal here….

Juror urges NZ justice minister to refuse compensation to exoneree

A juror has written to New Zealand’s justice minister urging him not to pay compensation to David Bain, an exoneree, after explaining that they had serious concerns about the conduct of the trial and in particular, the conduct of the jury deliberations. Read more here….

Bad, False & Exaggerated Science: An Infographic

There is a great infographic on scientific intergrity from clinicalpsychology. net for those interested in pushing for greater regulation and accountability for forensic science and educating others on the risks of scientific evidence. See infographic here…

Forensic DNA conference looking at potential for errors

Image

For people interested in Forensic DNA, there will be a ground-breaking international conference to discuss artifacts, errors and uncertain DNA evidence organized by Professor Vincenzo Pascali at the Università Cattolica del Sacro Cuore in Rome, Italy. Invited speakers (among many others) include M. Prinz, J. Mortera, B. Budowle, D. Balding, P. Gill, A. Carracedo, P. Dawid. A lot of time will be devoted to discussions and round tables.

The meeting is endorsed by the ISFG. The conference will be held from April 27-28, 2012. The conference programme and all registration details are now available from the conference homepage

Injustice to increase due to cuts in interpreter service?

Image

In the UK, we have already had cases where gross injustice has occurred because of a lack of proper translation during trials (see the infamous Satpal Ram case here… and here… where Bengali witness testimony was not translated because of a lack of an interpreter and the judge said that the court would ‘get the gist’ of their vital testimony with him translating even though he didn’t speak Bengali.) Now cuts to the justice system risk even greater, and more frequent injustice with cuts to the interpreter service. It cannot be underestimated how important it is for the suspect/defendant to be able to know what is being said, and for the authorities and juries etc. to understand exactly what the defendant is saying.

Read BBC news item here:

Court chaos follows interpreter change

“The government is hoping to save £18m a year by changing how interpreters are provided for court hearings – but it is said the new system is causing chaos and costly delays.”

And the fallout, just two weeks into the new private interpreter contract:

Courts given green light to hire own interpreters as ALS struggles to cope

Gallery

New Zealand considers alternatives to jury trial

This gallery contains 1 photos.

The Law Commission of New Zealand have announce an online public consultation looking at alternatives to the jury trial: Alternative models for prosecuting and trying criminal cases.  Some of the ‘alternatives’ posited include lone judges sitting with ‘semi-professional’ jurors. Some … Continue reading

New hopes for suspected miscarriage of justice victim

The new lawyer working for Jeremy Bamber (who also works pro bono for the University of Leeds Innocence Project) Simon McKay, has submitted new evidence from gun experts that completely undermines the prosecution case in a notorious mass murder, known in the UK as the ‘White House Farm’ murders (read about Jeremy Bamber’s 26 year campaign to overturn his conviction at his website here…)

.

Jeremy Bamber has maintained his innocence throughout his imprisonment for the murder of his family. Read more here… There are now renewed hopes that he may have a third appeal, and this time be successful.

Inquiry launched into the collapse of police corruption trial.

The murder of Lynette White in 1988 led to a terrible miscarriage of justice, with the wrongful imprisonment of three innocent men, known as the ‘Cardiff 3’. This case became the first to be re-investigated thoroughly after their conviction was overturned and the real perpetrator later tried and convicted. You can read more on the original case here...

This led to an unprecedented trial of eight police officers who were involved in the original wrongful convictions (see here…). This trial collapsed to the shock and dismay of many observers, and there is now to be an inquiry into the collapse of the trial and the conduct of the Crown Prosecution Service (read here…). There are some interesting news videos and interviews on the collapse of the trial on Channel 4 News here…

Closure of UK’s Forensic Science Service

The closure in March of the UK’s biggest forensic science service provider, the Forensic Science Service, has finally led to some news headlines. The New Scientist reported on a survey of forensic scientists, three quarters of whom believe the closure of the FSS will lead to an increase in miscarriages of justice. The weekend papers followed with articles on the closure and increased risk of miscarriages of justice in the Guardian, and a strongly worded editorial in the Observer newspaper: ‘Closing this pioneering unit is a foolish, short-sighted act.’