Damning forensic report ‘removed’ from journal now available… essential reading.

The case of Simon Hall in the UK has already made the headlines time and again, for all the wrong reasons. See just some of the coverage of the case collated here… and you can visit Simon’s great campaign website ‘Justice 4 Simon’ here… . This is an apparent miscarriage of justice that has gone on for far too long.

Now, another shocking twist in the tale.

Simon’s conviction rests on fibre analysis. For his appeal, a highly respected independent expert in fibres analysis – Tiernan Coyle, was employed to re-examine the evidence used to secure Simon’s conviction. He found multiple flaws in the evidence, and had no doubt that the conclusions reached were unsustainable. Unfortunately, this was not sufficient to win Simon his appeal.

As a respectable scientist, Tiernan Coyle then sought to publicise his findings to the wider forensic science community, sending his report to the scientific journal ‘Science and Justice’. Peer reviewers used terms like ‘valid’, ‘compelling’ and ‘highly convincing’ in their reviews, and commented on Coyle’s professional approach to the issues raised by the case, as well as stating that the report raises important issues that the fibres community needed to debate, which justified its publication. It was duly accepted and published. Subsequently, the article was withdrawn from Science and Justice, supposedly for ‘copyright’ reasons (the article showed images from the Forensic Science Service’s original analysis – although these images were used in the bundle of evidence at the trial and appeal so have been seen by anyone with access to the evidence).

Tiernan is then to be congratulated that rather than be silenced by this outrageous withdrawal of his paper from the journal, he has made it publicly available, with a short commentary on the story of how he was driven to this action.

I highly recommend that all those interested in forensic science and justice read the report. It demonstrates clearly how not only are people being wrongly convicted using flawed forensic science, but that even when discovery of flawed scientific conclusions are aired, it may not be enough to win freedom for the wrongly convicted. It is a salutary tale for those convinced that forensic science will end miscarriages of justice. It is also illuminating that while some in the forensic community wish to work to strengthen the scientific basis of their work, and share mistakes and assist in research, there are elements of the community that remain strongly resistant. This cannot be allowed to happen if progress is to be made.

Go to Tiernan Coyle’s website here…

The Case of Simon Hall

2 responses to “Damning forensic report ‘removed’ from journal now available… essential reading.

  1. Pingback: Blawg Review #320 – A Call to Arms « Amicae Curiae

  2. Thank you for your continued support and for highlighting this Gross INjustice….

    Simon remains strong and determined; even after suffering a decade of wrongful incarceration.

    We are determined to fight with all our might, alongside the Bristol Innocence Project here in the UK, until both Simon’s name is cleared and the real killers are apprehended and behind bars where they belonged 11 years ago!

    We strongly believe this was a malicious prosecution from the start…

    In December 2011 we provided the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) with a wealth of fresh submissions.

    Among the vast amount of submissions made; we are waiting for the CCRC to re-test the blood found at the crime scene believed to have come from one of the real killers.

    The CCRC describe this case as ‘complex’ – yet there is nothing complex about it! The only evidence said to link Simon to the crime scene were fibres; these fibres have been shown to not match!

    All other evidence pointed away from Simon and toward others!

    The police failed to properly investigate the real suspects, who were in the vilage that night, looking for houses to burgle!

    This case is one of the BIGGEST Miscarriages of Justice cases the UK has today!

    Many thanks again & Best wishes to all….

    Simon & Stephanie Hall

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s