Category Archives: Film/Cinema

Roman Polanski to Make Feature Film of Famous Wrongful Conviction Case in France….

Roman Polanski

Prior to my speaking engagements today in Krakow, Poland, I spent some time yesterday at the Oskar Schindler Factory Museum. There, I learned that filmmaker Roman Polanski spent time in the Jewish Ghetto in Krakow as child before escaping. At the museums were moving letters Roman had written as an 8-year old describing life in the Ghetto.

Upon returning to my room, I found this story that Polanski will be making a feature film of the wrongful conviction of Alfred Dreyfus, known as “The Dreyfus Affair” in France (see book about subject here). I found this connection fitting given Polanski’s background:

From EW.com:

Roman Polanski announced his next film would be a period espionage thriller based on the Dreyfus Affair, a turn-of-the-20th-century miscarriage of justice soaked in the era’s anti-Semitism. Captain Alfred Dreyfus was the first Jewish officer to be appointed to the French army’s general staff. Brilliant but unpopular with his peers, he was accused of high treason in 1894 when a German spy made off with French military secrets. Dreyfus was scapegoated and sentenced to life in prison, fueling populist anti-Semitic sentiments across the country. The facts would ultimately reveal that he had nothing to do with the betrayal, and his exile became a cause célèbre for those who demanded justice.

“I have long wanted to make a film about the Dreyfus Affair, treating it not as a costume drama but as a spy story,” said Polanski, who is calling his film D, in a statement. “In this way one can show its absolute relevance to what is happening in today’s world — the age-old spectacle of the witch-hunt of a minority group, security paranoia, secret military tribunals, out-of-control intelligence agencies, governmental cover-ups, and a rabid press.”

Polanski will direct a screenplay written by Robert Harris (The Ghost Writer), and production is scheduled to begin in Paris by the end of this year. Casting has yet to begin.

Dreyfus’ ordeal was most famously chronicled onscreen in 1958′s I Accuse!, in which José Ferrer played the heroic Capt. Dreyfus.

David Protess Reviews some of the Stunning Wrongful Conviction A-List Movies

David Protess, President Chicago Innocence Project in this Chicago Huffington Post, reviews and lays bare, the synopsis of what he considers the top ten list of wrongful conviction films and documentaries. He states that:

‘In the last two decades, wrongful convictions have become a particualarly popular subject of feature films and documentaries, prompted by the seemingly endless stream of high profile exonerations. A-list actors, directors and producers have jumped on the bandwagon to tell their stories. Despite the Hollywood firepower, however, the results have been mixed. Some movies about wrongful convictions have been stunningly good. Others, not so much’

Read full review here and may be you might be minded to make out time to buy the ones that catches your fancy.http://www.huffingtonpost.com/david-protess/wrongful-conviction-best-films_b_1156689.html

Sunday’s Quick Clicks…

  • In Dekalb County, Georgia, 2 men proven innocent of murder, and others charged instead, but police have yet to completely clear and remove the cloud hanging over the innocent men
  • Documentary film Mississippi Innocence, co-produced by Mississippi Innocence Project Director Tucker Carrington, to air this week
  • Number of rape cases with DNA where the DNA has not yet been tested “a national problem”
  • Arkansas death row inmate given new hearing after Medill Innocence Project demonstrates that DNA testing used to convict him may have been flawed
  • Mom’s faith outlasts her son’s wrongful conviction
  • North Carolina exoneree Robert Wilcoxson receives more than $500,000 in compensation for his 11 years of wrongful conviction
  • Bill introduced in Louisiana would speed up compensation payments to exonerees; in the past, many exonerees have had to wait for years for their compensation to come through

Thursday’s Quick Clicks…

Wednesday’s Quick Clicks…

Upcoming Feature Films on Wrongful Convictions….

Nicole Kidman stars in The Paperboy

From Indiewire.com:

Fresh off news confirming its appearance at the upcoming Cannes Film Festival, we now have a few new stills fromLee Daniels‘ “The Paperboy,” his forthcoming film featuring the leading trio of Nicole Kidman, Zac Efron and Matthew McConaughey.

An adaptation of a Pete Dexter novel, the ’60s-era thriller follows respected journalist Ward James (McConaughey) and his brother Jack (Efron), a college dropout, as they investigate the possible wrongful conviction of a death row inmate who was found guilty of killing a sheriff. Kidman has already been touted by producer Cassian Elwes as a performance to watch out for playing the convict’s correspondent love interest who Efron’s character falls for.

The film also co-stars John Cusack as the inmate; David Oyelowo as Yardley, who teams with Ward James on the investigation; and Scott Glenn as the James brothers’ father and the newspaper’s Editor-in-chief. And here’s a fun fact: the project was developed by Pedro Almodóvar for nearly a decade as his potential English-language debut. And while he eventually moved on, the script we saw last year was credited to both Almodóvar and Daniels, so perhaps it will have some of the former director’s edge? We’ll soon find out.

“The Paperboy” will play In Competition at Cannes. The festival runs from May 16-27.

+++++++++++

On the lighter side, Vince Vaughn will be starring in the remake of the classic American TV show Rockford Files, portraying a private investigator who spent 5 years in prison for a wrongful conviction

Monday’s Quick Clicks…

  • Website about the political persecution and alleged wrongful conviction of Adrian Nastase, the former Prime Minister of Romania
  • News video about exoneree Juan Melendez and his quest to end capital punishment
  • Juan Rivera at epicenter of discussions about false confessions; more here
  • Lockerbie: Case Closed….the documentary film about this alleged wrongful conviction

Saturday’s Quick Clicks…

  • Ohio Innocence Project wins new trial in Roger Dean Gillispie rape case based on new evidence of alternative suspect. Decision here
  • DNA frees innocent man, but not in typical way; he was in jail for failure to pay child support and DNA testing proved the child wasn’t his
  • Article about many successes of Innocence Project of Florida
  • Baltimore police department moving toward recorded interrogations
  • Michigan Innocence Clinic case is stalled because, astonishingly, the court has lost all the filings and paperwork in the clinic’s post-conviction murder case
  • Full version of documentary 6,149 Days, the story of the wrongful conviction of Greg Taylor in North Carolina
  • Great Wall Street Journal article on weakness of eyewitness id

Central Park case showed how media fuels injustice

Sarah Burns’ book The Central Park Five: A Chronicle of a City Wilding, is one of the best books on a wrongful-conviction case in recent years. The documentary she is now producing with her father, Ken Burns, promises to be equally compelling.

The book and film focus on the wrongful conviction of five black and Latino teenagers in 1990 for the particularly vicious assault and rape of a white woman while jogging through New York’s famed Central Park on the evening of April 20, 1989.

The case set off a media frenzy in the crime-plagued city that soon spread across the United States after police announced that the five youths had confessed that they had committed the rape as one of a series of random assaults they and other teens committed in the park that night, a process they supposedly called “wilding.”

Burns adeptly dissects this case the skill of a surgeon. She shows how police jumped to conclusions and then manipulated and intimidated the five boys into highly inconsistent confessions that were greatly at odds with the facts. In the process, Burns shows how the police ignored the similarities between the rape of Continue reading

Monday’s Quick Clicks…

Documentary Film Incendiary: The Willingham Case Wins Innocence Network Award

Incendiary: The Williamham Case won the Innocence Network Journalism Award last Friday at the annual convention in Kansas City. The film’s homepage is here. Press coverage about the film and its big win here. Purchase here. Get from iTunes here. From the news report:

When is a film more than a film? Movies become public artifacts once they leave their makers’ domains and enter the world. They’re judged by all sorts of artistic, social, and critical standards. But rarely are they judged by journalistic standards.
That, maybe, has something to do with the bar having been set so high when the evidence in Errol Morris’ The Thin Blue Lineresulted in an innocent man being released from death row – a Texas death row, I might add.Texans convicted of murder on dubious evidence has again become award-winning subject matter for two Continue reading

New Documentary Tells of Wrongful Conviction of Medicine Man…

A couple of impressionable young children pressured into alleging molestation and pointing the finger because of a family feud and manipulative games between “grown-ups” that they don’t understand. Procedural errors in the investigation and conviction, which are ignored by the appellate courts. Later, after the children have grown up, they recant, and pass polygraphs. They show remorse and frustration, and convincingly explain why they were made to lie when they were children. Evidence about the family feud that led to the false charges is plentiful. Jurors sign affidavits saying they would not have convicted had this been known. Prosecutors and courts don’t care. Innocent man languishes in prison (in this case, until death).

Sound familiar? To anyone who has worked with an Innocence Project, it certainly would. Like with our own cases involving this all-to-common fact pattern, this is what happened to Lakota medicine man Douglas White. A new documentary, Holy Man: The USA v. Douglas White (trailer here) tells of this heartbreaking phenomenon in the context of Native American spirituality and reservation life. The filmmakers’ shock at how the prosecutors and courts refused to listen to reason, and bent over backwards to avoid considering the new evidence, will strike close to home. Details here.

Wednesday’s Quick Clicks…

Friday’s Quick Clicks…

Lockerbie Bombing Case: A Wrongful Conviction?

Abdelbaset al-Megrahi, who was convicted in the Lockerbie bombing, released a book Monday that sets forth his claims of innocence. The abstract of the book, entitled Meghari: You Are My Jury, states:

You know me as the Lockerbie bomber. I know that I’m innocent. Here, for the first time, is my true story: how I came to be blamed for Britain’s worst mass murder, my nightmare decade in prison and the truth about my controversial release. Please read it and decide for yourself.

You are now my jury. – Abdelbaset al-Megrahi

Two documentary films being released also call his conviction “Britain’s biggest miscarriage of justice,” and allegedly demolish the key witness against him. The films also shed light on exculpatory material that was not previously disclosed (what we call Brady violations in the U.S.). More here, here, and here. For a rebuttal, read this

A Separation: Oscar Winning Film Raises Wrongful Conviction Issues in Iran

A Separation won best foreign language film at the Academy Awards Sunday night. Not only is this a really interesting, well-acted movie, but the plot revolves around a possible wrongful conviction in progress. As the story unfolds, and the viewer learns more and more about the case, one gets a sense of how the Iranian criminal justice system operates. The judge in the case hears “evidence” and rules on the merits in a small office with each witness and the defendant just sort of hashing it out and arguing with each other until the judge gets a feel for what he thinks happened. In the process, questions are raised about the reliability of different forms of evidence, and how wrongful convictions can happen to anyone-even the respected and privileged in society. The bottom line is that the film is wonderful, and I’d recommend to anyone regardless of his or her interest in wrongful convictions or comparative criminal justice systems. I’m not the only one who liked it, as it got a rare 99% approval rate from the critics on rottentomatoes.com. Save it to your Netflix queue here.

Oscar Watch: “Paradise Lost 3: Purgatory” Up for Best Documentary Film Tonight

Paradise Lost 3: Purgatory, the documentary film about the West Memphis 3, is up for best documentary film at the Academy Awards tonight. Parents of the victims are angry about the nomination, claiming that the film glorifies the defendants.

UPDATE: IT DID NOT WIN

New Documentary Film From Philippines on Wrongful Conviction Case…

The end of this trailer says, “The minute you forget about justice, anywhere in the world, that’s the beginning of the breakdown of society.” The film is Give Up Tommorow, and you can see the powerful trailer here. Word from those who have seen it is that it’s terrific. Here’s the summary:

As a tropical storm beats down on the Philippine island of Cebu, two sisters leave work and never make it home…

GIVE UP TOMORROW exposes a Kafkaesque extravaganza populated by flamboyantly corrupt public officials, drug dealers, cops on the take, and a frenzied legal and media circus. It is also an intimate family drama focused on the near mythic struggle of two angry and sorrowful mothers who have dedicated more than a decade to executing or saving one young man, Paco Larrañaga.

Wednesday’s Quick Clicks…

Monday’s Quick Clicks….

  • Northern California Innocence Project client Maurice Caldwell adjusts to life on the outside one year after being exonerated…..
  • the Supreme Court of India has ruled that mere “procedural errors” alone cannot be a basis for overturning a criminal conviction…there must also be a miscarriage of justice in the case before the conviction can be quashed….
  • Amanda Knox signs a multi-million dollar book deal….
  • a former prosecutor (now a judge) in Texas faces an inquiry for allegedly hiding exclulpatory evidence in a case….related commentary by Nancy Petro here….
  • Mississippi Innocence Project Director Tucker Carrington is a featured speaker at the University of Arkansas….
  • Geography-the rural/urban divide-impacts quality of justice in South Africa…
  • a documentary film on the West Memphis 3 wrongful conviction case nominated for Academy Award….
  • Massachusetts passed bill giving inmates access to DNA testing to prove their innocence….
  • this week is Innocence Week at Cardiff Law School in Wales….